The Meaning We Attach to Our Strengths
Summary
the author explores the complex nature of personal traits by examining their own perceived strength of adaptability. A conversation with a mentor reveals that strengths often carry hidden “shadows,” demonstrating how an adaptable person might simultaneously exhibit rigidity in areas like culture or religion. Drawing on the concept of optimal use and the Islamic practice of muḥāsabah (self-accounting), the passage emphasizes that strengths are not inherently perfect and require careful direction and self-awareness. Ultimately, the author concludes that true maturity involves looking beneath our strengths to understand when to be flexible and when to remain firm, ensuring these traits serve what is right rather than merely reinforcing a rigid personal identity.
ⓘ This summary is generated by Ai
I have always considered adaptability one of my strengths. When circumstances change, I adjust. When something does not go according to plan, I usually find another way. I can reorganise, accommodate and keep moving.
Recently, I was having a conversation with my mentor about strengths and the shadows that can sometimes accompany them. Adaptability came up quite quickly. Then she asked me to consider something I had never associated with before.
Rigidity.
I was genuinely surprised. If I was adaptable, how could rigidity possibly sit alongside it?
But as we explored it, I began to understand what she meant. I can be very flexible with circumstances, people and changing plans. But that does not necessarily mean I am flexible in every area of my thinking.
Religion and culture came up as two areas where I could be far more rigid, where certain things felt non-negotiable.
That made me pause. Not because firmness around faith is necessarily a problem. There are principles within our religion that are not ours to simply reshape because circumstances change. But culture is different. Sometimes what feels non-negotiable may have been inherited, absorbed or repeated for so long that we have never really examined why we hold onto it.
It made me realise that adaptability and rigidity did not necessarily cancel each other out. Both could exist within me. And perhaps more importantly, I did not leave that conversation thinking, “Rigidity is my weakness and now I need to fix it.” I left wondering how well we really know the qualities we call our strengths.
A Strength Can Have a Shadow
We tend to put qualities into neat categories: flexibility is good, rigidity is bad; patience is good, impatience is bad. But qualities do not always work that neatly.
Research into character strengths supports this. Ryan Niemiec describes strengths in terms of underuse, overuse and optimal use, suggesting that a strength works best when it is used to the right degree and in the right situation.[1]
That helped me make sense of the conversation with my mentor. A shadow does not have to mean that there is something wrong with the strength. It may simply reveal something we have not noticed because we have been looking at the quality from only one side.
Patience can help us endure, but there are times when patience becomes silence around something that needs addressing. Responsibility can make us dependable, but it can also leave us carrying things that were never ours to carry. And adaptability can be a genuine strength without requiring us to adapt to everything. That last part mattered to me.
Strength Needs Direction
Islam does not ask us to become less strong. The Prophet ﷺ said:
“The strong believer is better and more beloved to Allah than the weak believer, while there is good in both.”[2]
But Islam also changes our understanding of what strength looks like. The Prophet ﷺ said:
“The strong is not the one who overcomes people by his strength, but the strong is the one who controls himself while in anger.”[3]
I find the distinction important. Strength itself is not the problem. What matters is what we do with it and what is directing it.
The same is true of firmness. There are moments when refusing to move is exactly what is required. A boundary may need to remain a boundary. A religious principle does not become negotiable simply because holding it has become uncomfortable.
But there are also moments when what I call firmness may simply be my preference. Or habit. Or pride. Or something I have inherited culturally and never thought to question. From the outside, those things can look remarkably similar.
Looking Beneath the Strength
This is where muḥāsabah, self-accounting, became relevant to the reflection for me. Allah says:
“O believers! Be mindful of Allah, and let every soul see what deeds it has sent forth for tomorrow…”[4]
Muḥāsabah asks for honesty. Not endless suspicion of ourselves, but a willingness to look beneath what we are doing. Why am I adapting here? Why am I refusing to adapt there? Is this a principle I need to protect, or simply something I find difficult to release?
That kind of questioning becomes even more important when a strength has become part of how we see ourselves. “I am the strong one. I am the patient one. I am the one who copes. I am the one who adjusts.”
Sometimes we can become so attached to being that person that we continue performing the strength even when the situation requires something different. The adaptable person may keep bending when a boundary is needed. The strong person may struggle to admit they need help. The patient person may stay quiet when it is time to speak.
A strength should serve us in doing what is right. We should not have to serve the identity we have built around the strength.
Returning to Rigidity
I eventually came back to the word that had initially made me uncomfortable: rigidity. I still do not think it is as simple as saying rigidity is bad and adaptability is good.
There are things I should be willing to reconsider, particularly when what I am defending comes more from habit, preference or culture than principle. And there are other things where flexibility would not necessarily be growth at all.
That is probably what I took most from the conversation. I still consider adaptability one of my strengths. I just understand it differently now. Being adaptable does not mean I must always bend. Being firm does not automatically mean I am rigid. The harder work is knowing the difference.
Our strengths, temperaments and abilities are blessings from Allah, but perhaps part of carrying those blessings well is being willing to examine them too. Not only asking where they help us, but noticing what may be happening beneath them.
Perhaps maturity is not about collecting more strengths or eliminating every shadow. Perhaps it is learning to carry what Allah has given us with greater awareness, humility and responsibility.
Knowing our strengths is useful. Understanding what is happening beneath them may tell us far more.
Ryan M. Niemiec, “Finding the Golden Mean: The Overuse, Underuse, and Optimal Use of Character Strengths,” Counselling Psychology Quarterly 32, nos. 3–4 (2019): 453–471. https://doi.org/10.1080/09515070.2019.1617674. ↑
Sahih Muslim, no. 2664, Kitab al-Qadar (Book of Destiny), chapter on strength and seeking Allah’s help; graded sahih https://sunnah.com/muslim:2664 (accessed 13 October 2026). ↑
Sahih al-Bukhari no. 6114, Kitab al-Adab, Bab al-Hadhar min al-Ghaḍab (Caution against Anger); Sahih Muslim, no. 2609, Kitab al-Birr wa’l-Silah wa’l-Adab, chapter on controlling anger; both sahih https://sunnah.com/bukhari:6114 and https://sunnah.com/muslim:2609 (accessed 13 October 2026). ↑
Qur’an 59:18, translation by Dr Mustafa Khattab, The Clear Quran. https://quran.com/59/18 (accessed 13 October 2026). ↑
Submit Work